Saturday, 15 June 2024

Reviews of Caledonian Voice and English Voice.
MEMBERS AND SUPPORTERS of the National Liberal Party may be interested to know that two of its national publications – Caledonian Voice and English Voice – have received a very positive review on the well-known and popular Counter Culture web-site.

Both publications were reviewed by Andrew Hunter (to read the original review click here: and were posted up towards the end of last year.

Under the title Federalism for Britain: The NLP Launches two papers for England & Scotland the reviewer notes that both Caledonian Voice (CV) and English Voice (EV) have “eye-catching mastheads and lead articles” and “are produced to a high standard with impressive layouts that attract the reader.”

Counter Culture is probably better known for its fairly in-depth coverage of the annual Edinburgh Fringe Festival, which, according to its web-site – see for more details – claims to be “the largest arts festival in the world and takes place every August for three weeks in Scotland’s capital city.”

Counter Culture also covers a variety of other subjects such as local history, music, fim and so on. However, as far as we’re aware, this is the first time it’s reviewed party political publications of any sort.

The NLP would be interested to know if there are any more reviews out there. Also, we’re interested in featuring more reviews of our various publications – Caledonian Voice, English Voice, Isle of Wight Voice (issues 1 and 2), Kent Voice, Liberty & Nation, New Horizon (issues 1 and 2) or St. Andrews Voice. If any of our readers fancy themselves as a literary critic (!) please e-mail us at and we’ll send you FREE pdfs of any (or all) of these puiblications.

In the meantime, printed below is the aforementioned published review of CV and EV.

Federalism for Britain: The NLP Launches two papers for England & Scotland.

JULY saw the launch of two new publications by the National Liberal Party (NLP), English Voice (EV), and Caledonian Voice (CV). As their titles suggest, the former is produced for England and the latter is aimed at Scottish readers and thus they will function as the national NLP papers for England and Scotland. Both papers are currently produced in a double-sided A4 format with the front page comprising eye-catching mastheads and lead articles with the reverse giving readers a general introduction to the NLP, its policies and its New Horizon e-zine. EV is currently available online while CV is available both online and in printed form for distribution door to door.

The common theme of the first issue of both publications can be summed-up as ‘Federalism for Britain’ and revives the concept of ‘The British Family of Nations’ which was a strong strand of de-centralist thinking in the 1980’s which sought to strengthen local and regional identities and culture and devolve power away from central government and down to the ordinary people. At the time this represented a radical departure from what had been hitherto orthodox policy which looked very much to a centralist British Government and a blanket British identity. With the question over Scotland’s future within the United Kingdom and calls for England to have its own Parliament, EV and CV bring a fresh view to these debates.

CV leads with The Independence Referendum…..Is there a Third Way? and puts forward the option of Devo-Max as alternative to both outright separation of Scotland from the rest of the UK and the status quo. Devo-Max seeks to devolve as much power to Holyrood from Westminster as possible leaving only issues common to the whole of the UK such as defence and foreign affairs vested centrally. The NLP’s distinctive stance in calling for the establishment of an English Parliament and the introduction of citizens’ initiative referenda along the Swiss lines are also highlighted:

“The NLP supports the creation of an English Parliament and encouraging people across the United Kingdom to become involved in open and accountable systems of government at both local and national level that enable ordinary citizens to participate in the decision making processes that affect their daily lives. The NLP calls for the introduction of Swiss-style citizens’ initiative referenda to ensure that the majority can be heard on issues that the political elite would rather ignore”.

EV carries the bold headline DEVO-MAX FOR THE ENGLISH and pulls no punches when it lays out the anomaly of Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland having their own parliaments or regional assemblies while England has none:

“DISCRIMINATION! That’s the only way to describe the way the Westminster establishment treats England and the English people. One of the main reasons England is discriminated against is because every other nation in Britain has some form of self-government. But England has none!”

EV then continues to point out other areas where England is disadvantaged relative to the other parts of the United Kingdom, such as the “West Lothian Question”, posed by the Labour MP Tam Dalyell back in 1977, which highlights how MPs from Scotland, Northern Ireland and Wales can vote on purely English matters in the House of Commons while under devolution English MPs could not vote on the same matters concerning those other parts of the UK. EV puts forward the creation of an English parliament under Devo-Max as the way to address the imbalance with the rest of the United Kingdom.

Both English Voice and Caledonian Voice are produced to a high standard with impressive layouts that attract the reader. CV has been produced in printed form with the aim of being distributed especially in small towns and rural areas that do not often see any form of political campaigning. It will be interesting to see what the response is. Readers interested in distributing CV door to door in their areas should contact the NLP’s office for details of how copies can be sent to them. I understand that issue two of both papers should be out before the end of the year.

Both papers are also available via e-mail. To get hold of them, e-mail and ask for your FREE pdf copy of Caledonian Voice and English Voice.

Reviewed by Andrew Hunter

  • Print
  • Digg
  • StumbleUpon
  • Facebook
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • Twitter
  • Google Bookmarks
  • Add to favorites
  • blogmarks
  • Blogosphere
  • Google Buzz
  • PDF
  • email
  • Live
  • MSN Reporter
  • MyShare
  • MySpace
  • Technorati

By continuing to use the site, you agree to the use of cookies. more information

The cookie settings on this website are set to "allow cookies" to give you the best browsing experience possible. If you continue to use this website without changing your cookie settings or you click "Accept" below then you are consenting to this.